TO: Dr. Joe
Scarcella
FROM: Phil Fournier
DATE: 12/16/2004
RE: 503, WA1, Fournier
The purpose of EVOC 503 WA1
was to prepare an Individual Education Plan for one of the students in a course
that I teach. The following six criteria were specified:
The following sources of
information were used relative to this assignment:
I believe that the attached
proposal meets all six of above listed criteria and respectfully request full
credit: one point for meeting each of the above listed criteria.
Individual
Education Plan for student Jerry Steen
(Name changed to protect
confidentiality)
Course description – Automotive Engine
Performance Level 1 is an intermediate level course which employs both lecture
and laboratory educational strategies.
Student
description – Jerry
Steen is a male, age 35, who is a good student with a real desire to grasp the
material and improve his diagnostic ability.
In fact, as he is employed as a technician, his success in this class is
imperative to his continued success in his job.
Problem
description – Jerry
is extremely hard of hearing. Though he
wears two hearing aids, he cannot really distinguish words unless he can
lip-read. The difficulty lies in the use
of educational aids such as vides tapes and DVD’s and the instructor’s habit of
talking while drawing with his face to the whiteboard. If the multi-media products are not
captioned, Jerry gains no benefit from them at all, as he cannot make out the
words. The problem is compounded in the
lab, where hearing is a problem even for those without disabilities, due to the
noise of the engine running.
Instructional
Strategy – Mt.
San Jacinto College has a very good DSP&S (Disabled Students Programs &
Services) department. Captioning of
instructional video tapes and DVDs is available as well as sign-language
interpreters and other high-tech listening devices. The difficulty for the instructor is this
from DSP&S “Bring documentation of your disability and functional
limitations from a professional; such as a physician or psychologist.” Jerry insists (and to a point this instructor
agrees) that a physician’s note about his deafness is entirely
superfluous. His disability is obvious,
particularly due the strange way he speaks since he cannot hear himself. Nevertheless, help for Jerry, and hence for
the instructor will not be forth-coming unless Jerry will follow the rules of
the DSP&S department and get his physician’s documentation of his condition. Once that obstacle has been overcome, help in
this class and future classes will be readily available and Jerry’s learning
can progress at a much faster rate. The
urgency of following through with this request has been made plain to Jerry and
he now understands that taking this step is in his own best interests. In the mean time, as his instructor I have
placed Jerry in the front of the class room on the right side so he can see my
lips. Additionally, though I often write
on the white board, I have trained myself to not talk to the black board, but rather towards
Jerry so he can benefit. This
practice is nearly impossible in the lab, so Jerry’s learning there will be
limited until an interpreter is available to assist him.
Evaluation – Jerry’s test scores at present are very low as much
of the material on the quizzes comes from lecture notes, which he cannot take
while reading lips. Once Jerry has an
interpreter or a listening device, he should be able to take notes of his own
and study from them. Jerry’s test scores
will be evaluated at that time to see if improvement can be recognized. If not, steps will be taken to insure he gets
additional assistance in note-taking.